Cream stucco home entry with oak-framed glazing, a warm wood soffit and shell-concrete terrace beside a sand live oak.

After the MarketCafe, Seagrove's Holiday Season Moves to the Dinner Hour

The notice went up on a Thursday evening in October. At 5:49 p.m. on Oct. 22, SoWal posted the announcement from Hartley Restaurant Group. Seagrove Village MarketCafe and its younger sibling, Watersound Village Market in Inlet Beach, were closing effective immediately, and that Thursday was the last day of service at both.

The building started in 1949 as a gas station and general store, AL.com reported, citing Southern Living. Over the decades it became a casual stop for beachgoers, known for fried shrimp baskets, tacos, burgers and salads. George and Ann Hartley bought it in 1999. In their own post, quoted by AL.com, they wrote: "Following Hurricane Isaias, we have made the painful decision to close Seagrove Village Market, effective immediately."

Isaias came ashore near Destin and Miramar Beach around 8:30 p.m. on Friday, Oct. 10. Twelve days later, Seagrove had lost a kitchen that had fed the neighborhood for more than 75 years. Heading into Thanksgiving and December, every holiday table you can confirm inside Seagrove opens in the evening or needs a reservation. The Hartleys' remaining restaurant, a short walk away in Seagrove Village, is now the hub for all of it.

The kitchen that stayed open

Surfing Deer sits at 2743 County Highway 30A, on the corner of 30A and 395, and calls itself the heart of Seagrove Village. It took damage in the storm too, but SoWal reported that the Hartleys could keep it fully open for normal hours.

Normal hours at Surfing Deer are evening hours. According to the restaurant's site, it serves Monday through Saturday from 4:30 to 9 p.m. and closes on Sundays, with indoor, outdoor and high-top bar seating. Takeout runs in a short window from 5 to 6:30 p.m. A fall and winter 2026–27 dinner menu is posted.

The practical detail from the announcement matters for anyone holding a gift card. Gift cards from any Hartley Restaurant Group restaurant can be used at Surfing Deer for dining or merchandise. That means a MarketCafe or Watersound Village Market card tucked into a kitchen drawer still works, just across the corner and after 4:30.

George Hartley, founder and owner of the group, spoke to the future in the statement SoWal published:

"We look forward to serving you and your families as we create more fabulous food and colorful stories for years to come."

The same announcement said the family plans to take this time to work out what comes next. It also invited the community to join the group's email list for updates.

A season that starts at 4:30

The shared tables of late November and early December sit in the evening, or behind a reservation or a prepaid order.

Date Place Hours What it takes
Thursday, Nov. 26 Café Thirty-A, 3899 E Scenic Hwy 30A 11:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. dine-in Reservation required
Thursday, Nov. 26 Café Thirty-A takeout Pickup 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. Phone order and a credit card
Thursday, Nov. 26 Old Florida Fish House, 33 Heron's Watch Way Thanksgiving Grand Buffet Listed on the restaurant's events page
Saturday, Nov. 28 Seaside Holiday Parade & Turn on the Town 3 to 8 p.m. Free to attend
Saturday, Dec. 5 SEASIDE Holiday Market, Central Square 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. Walk-in
Sunday, Dec. 6 Old Florida Fish House, "Still Standing" 6:30 to 9 p.m. show Dinner arrivals at 5 p.m.

The Seaside market on Dec. 5 is the only daytime walk-in on the list. Seaside is also the only place on it outside Seagrove.

Thanksgiving at Café Thirty-A, priced two ways

Café Thirty-A is Seagrove's long-standing reservation dinner. On the restaurant's Thanksgiving 2026 page, the holiday works out to two very different checks.

Dine-in costs $105 per person and $35 for children 12 and under, before tax and gratuity, served from 11:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. by reservation only. The meal has three courses and dessert. It opens with Butternut Squash Bisque or She Crab Soup, then the Autumn Arcadian Salad with Fuji apples, dried cherries and goat cheese. For the main course, guests choose the Southern Deep-Fried Brined Turkey with the classic sides, Pan Seared Snapper over wild mushroom risotto, or Cajun Shrimp & Grits made with what the kitchen calls its famous grits. The Grilled Filet Mignon adds $15 and the Crab Cake Entrée adds $20. Dessert is crème brûlée, traditional pumpkin pie or chocolate pecan pie.

Takeout for six costs $400 plus tax. That's about $67 a person, compared with $105 at the table before tax and tip. The package includes the same deep-fried brined turkey, whole or carved, plus:

  • A choice of butternut squash soup or the Autumn Arcadian Salad
  • Green bean casserole, traditional stuffing, sweet potato casserole, mashed potatoes, giblet gravy and rolls
  • Pumpkin pie or double chocolate pecan pie

Extra sides for six are $40 each, as is extra soup or pie. Extra gravy is $10 and extra rolls are $15. A turkey on its own is $125.

Ordering follows its own clock. You call 850-231-2166, extension 1, between 11 a.m. and 4 p.m., and a valid credit card confirms the order. Pickup is between 11 a.m. and 5 p.m. on Thanksgiving Day, with times assigned based on availability. Kitchen capacity sets the limit on takeout, so the earlier call gets the better pickup time.

One housekeeping note. Café Thirty-A's homepage still shows a closure notice for Nov. 30 to Dec. 25, 2025, next to its daily dinner hours from 4:30 p.m., with reservations required. That notice covers last year.

Heron's Watch Way and the weekend next door

Old Florida Fish House, set back on Heron's Watch Way, has two dates on the calendar. Its special events page lists a Thanksgiving Grand Buffet for Nov. 26. On Sunday, Dec. 6, it hosts "Still Standing – A Tribute to Elton John." Dinner guests arrive at 5 p.m., show-only guests start arriving at 6 p.m., and the show runs 6:30 to 9 p.m., according to the 30A.com listing.

The Saturday after Thanksgiving belongs to Seaside, just west along 30A. The Seaside Holiday Parade & Turn on the Town runs Nov. 28 from 3 to 8 p.m. It includes a parade on 30A, a performance at Krier Plaza, the tree lighting and photos with Santa. Proceeds from parade registration benefit Point Washington Medical Clinic. Since Surfing Deer serves Saturdays from 4:30, a post-parade dinner back in Seagrove Village fits the evening.

Saturday, Dec. 5, offers more daylight than any other date this season. The SEASIDE Holiday Market fills Central Square with local artisans and makers from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. Farther east, the Rosemary Beach Holiday Tour of Homes runs the same day from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m., starting from 28 N Barrett Square. Proceeds go to Alaqua Animal Refuge and Caring & Sharing of South Walton.

The daylight hours take a phone call

For decades, a daytime meal in Seagrove could mean walking up to the Market with sandy feet. The neighborhood still has daytime kitchens and counters along 30A. They include Prema Organic Cafe at 3557 E County Hwy 30A, Dough Sea Dough Donuts and Goatfeathers Seagrove Market, both at 4042 E County Hwy 30A, and The Perfect Pig at 4281 E County Hwy 30A. Toward Eastern Lake you'll find Beachy Bean Coffee Co. and Coastside 30A at 5221 E County Hwy 30A, and Kahve & Cream at 5311 E County Hwy 30A. Pecan Jacks Seagrove is at 4771 E County Hwy 30A, and the 30A General Store sits at 43 Cassine Way. A month after the storm, call ahead or check a recent post from the business before planning a morning around any of them.

The same goes for the beach at the end of the walk. As of Oct. 27, the Seagrove Regional Beach Access at 3910 E County Hwy 30A had its restrooms and dune-walkover steps open, its ADA ramp closed, and cleanup still underway. Walton County Tourism keeps a running Hurricane Isaias updates page for beach accesses and businesses, and it is the place to check on the morning of a beach day.

The Market's gift cards now work at Surfing Deer. The Thanksgiving turkey is a phone call to Café Thirty-A between 11 and 4. The Hartleys have said they will take their time deciding what comes next in Seagrove Village.

Lisa and Anna have watched Seagrove Village change for many years, and the closing of a place that dates to 1949 is the kind of change they follow closely. If you own here, or are thinking about what this corner of 30A will become, LaFlure & Vice would welcome the conversation. Request a personalized consultation.

Let's Get Started

Work with them for luxe, coastal real estate service in the 30A region. Their blend of coastal living expertise, architectural elegance, and personal care ensures your buying or selling journey is upscale, seamless, and truly yours.

Follow Me on Instagram